Acting Pastors
| 1906 – 1921 | E.A. Sutherland |
| 1921 – 1922 | Ben Leach |
| 1923 – 1925 | N.C. Wilson |
| 1926 – 1934 | E.A. Sutherland |
Conference Appointed Senior Pastors
| 1935 – 1943 | Howard J. Welch |
| 1943 – 1947 | R.I. Keats |
| 1947 – 1951 | Glen Coon |
| 1951 – 1954 | R.L. Kimble |
| 1954 – 1959 | O.J. Mills |
| 1959 – 1961 | Hubert T. Anderson |
| 1961 – 1965 | Warren Wittenberg |
| 1965 – 1972 | Jack W. Clark |
| 1972 – 1974 | E.R. Gienger |
| 1974 – 1978 | Harley Schander |
| 1979 – 1984 | Bob Hunter |
| 1984 – 1994 | Gary Rustad |
| 1994 – 1995 | James Davidson |
| 1996 – 2010 | Lynn Schlisner |
| 2010 – 2012 | Fred Fuller |
| 2012 – 2012 | Leclair “Litch” Litchfield (Interim) |
| 2013 – 2015 | Byron Corbett |
| 2016 – | Ken Wetmore |